When Donald Miller’s Book “Blue Like Jazz” was published in 2003 it caught many people’s attention. It especially appealed to those who grew up in a conservative church background who struggled to resolve the shame or embarrassment they may have felt for being “Christian” as a result of their seemingly culturally-disconnected, religious experience. The book chronicles Donald Miller’s personal journey to reconcile his own exposure to a hypocritical, imperfect, Southern Baptist upbringing with his personal search for a God who is much more than his religious experience made Him out to be.
Some more conservative critics of the book did not care for the license of exploratory freedom it seemed to endorse for the curious, Christian college student. Some people accused Miller of thinking himself a modern-day, C.S. Lewis who endorsed drinking, philosophizing, and sitting on rooftops and smoking pipes while contemplating the meaning of life. Despite the controversy, I personally enjoyed the book although I would not completely align with Miller’s convictions.
Recently, I had the opportunity to view a pre-screening of Steve Taylor’s movie version of the book, premiering in a limited number of theaters April 13, 2012. As with most books-made-to-movies it really isn’t a movie version of the book but rather a spin-off of the main story line. After the screening I had the privilege to hear from producer Steve Taylor, author Donald Miller, and main character Marshall Allman who plays Don’s character in the film. It was a healthy experience to hear from them personally instead of reading what others may take away from their intentions for making the film.
As this is not an official movie review, I will not summarize the plot, storyline, etc. However, the purpose for this post is to lend a few warnings and some advice for those who may be wondering whether or not to give the movie a chance.
First, if you are a card-carrying Southern Baptist you will most likely be offended by the movie. In fact, you may not make it 10 minutes before contemplating walking out. I do not say this to stir the pot of controversy; I simply offer this as a caution that you may want to save your money. Let me explain. Miller’s own experience in his Southern Baptist upbringing is hokey, embarrassing, and hypocritical. He also does not qualify this as a unique experience but rather labels it “Southern Baptist” and leaves it at that. Having been raised a Southern Baptist, as well as run away from some of the same things Donald ran away from before truly pursuing Christ with abandon, I resonate with what he communicates in the film. However, I do not endorse that this is the only culture one will find in a Southern Baptist church. In fact, I am the singles pastor at a Southern Baptist Church currently and there are great, authentic, God-honoring things happening in multiple areas here. Regardless, if you salute the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) with the same fervor as you salute the American flag and the Christian flag, save your money.
On the other hand, if you can prepare yourself to fight against the non-spiritual gift of “being offended,” you just may discover some very real questions and redeeming answers that are currently running through the mainstream thoughts of the 20-40 somethings across our country, today. For anyone who has run the gauntlet of the college party life only to come up wanting, this film will resonate. For anyone who has contemplated the mystery of God and how to reconcile that with the pull of worldly temptations, this film will resonate. For anyone who has ever been embarrassed to share your faith for fear of rejection, this film will resonate. If you are a Christian and have friends in the party crowds who seem disinterested in religious matters, you should bring them to this film; it just may resonate. Their eternity hangs in the balance.
A few more precautions: Donald Miller does not resolve his less-than-favorable memory of his SBC roots, with one exception. In the movie, Miller’s character admits that while he was originally ashamed of his church culture, he later came to admit he was actually ashamed of Jesus (sobering revelation). Also, this is not your typical “Christian” film nor is it even a family film (check the ratings). Rather, it is a film designed for anyone, college-age or older, who has ever struggled with reconciling their less-than-perfect experience in religious culture with the true nature of the God of the Universe.
Spend the ten bucks. You be the judge. It will be worth your time…